prioritisation of ideas
of ideas when incomplete information is available
game-changing innovation
where the impact on the business can be managed.
The Pentathlon Framework can be used to describe a structured process
that removes the risk of failure as ideas progress through the 'Innovation Funnel'.
2 > Ideas Generation
to problems and challenges.
of ideas to market
to move ideas from conception, through implementation
to market in an environment of high uncertainty.
where it is most needed
selection and implementation, identifying the business priorities
and ensuring senior management buy-in at an early stage.
The strategy may recommend acquisition, a new supply chain or new skills.
5 > People & organisations
tension between taking risks and minimising
failure as products and services near market.
Portfolio Management techniques
Managers face many challenges when deciding how to allocate resources to develop new ideas : –
- Intrinsic value – some projects are worth doing for themselves
- Right portfolio – there will be a set of projects that meet the overall needs of the organisation
- Retaining good people – some ideas will be rejected but it is important that the people behind them don’t take it personally.
One of our themes is about managing the R&D pipeline and it explores these issues further.
Below is one approach that is gaining interest.
Portfolio Management
Portfolio Management (PM) techniques are systematic ways of looking at a set of projects or activities or even business units, in order to reach an optimum balance between risks and returns, stability and growth, attractions and drawbacks in order to make the best use of usually limited resources.
In many organisations, the uncertainty surrounding individual projects leads them to place considerable emphasis on the development of a portfolio of activities which is aimed to balancing risk and reward in such a way as to reduce the overall uncertainty.
One useful approach to this task is to consider the innovation process from idea to implementation alongside certain variables, such as future cash flow projections and resource requirements.
Joe Tidd and John Bessant explore a number of techniques specially suited for Portfolio Management at the strategic and operational level.
Read more:
Portfolio Management Tools, Joe Tidd and John Bessant, www.innovation-portal.info (John Wiley and Sons Ltd)
Recommended by Charlotte Stone, post by R&D Today admin
Articles relating to selection & prioritisation
Which projects are most suited to an Agile approach?
A survey of companies attending STIM events through 2019 and 2020 showed that there is growing interest in the application of Agile project management processes. In discussions it was revealed that more guidance on the types of projects where...
Read more
Accelerating new product development
"Now is the time to re-think the firm’s innovation process and methods," argues Robert G.Cooper, best known for the development of StageGate, a new product development process that is widely used by multinational organisations. In his recent paper “Accelerating...
Read more
Absorptive Capacity Audit
Utilising this audit, the reader can assess the strengths and weaknesses in their ability to find, assimilate and use new knowledge to advantage - absorptive capacity.
Read more
Integrating sustainable value thinking into technology forecasting: a configurable toolset
Sustainable value gives longer term business return because it delivers the triple bottom line of economic, environmental and social value. However, current assessment methods are essentially audits and can only be used when every detail of an innovation are...
Read more
Effective decision-making in R&D: a case study using biofilms
Deciding which project to progress when the technologies and applications are diverse is a challenge that faces many innovation managers. In this guest blog Mark Richardson, CEO of the National Biofilms Innovation Centre, discusses how he resolved this problem...
Read more
Choosing The Best Metric For Measuring The Effectiveness Of R&D
Measuring the effectiveness of R&D can be a challenge. Larry Schwartz led an IRI investigation to understand how managers define R&D effectiveness the metrics they use to measure it.
Read more
