Skip to content
Generic filters
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Search in excerpt
Filter by Article Type
Papers
Events
Tools
Funding Articles
Case Studies
Resources
Opportunities
Theme Editor Blogs
Filter by Categories
Business model innovation
Ideation and creativity in R&D
Latest news
Managing international R&D
Managing technology platforms
Managing the R&D pipeline
Open innovation
Outsourcing R&D
Project valuation and selection
R&D strategy
Roadmapping
Stage gate processes
Technology intelligence
  • Home
  • About
    • About R&D Today
    • Contributors
    • R&D Publications
    • R&D Today newsletter archive
  • Themes
    • R&D Management
      • Rationale for key themes
      • Ideation and creativity in R&D
      • Managing international R&D
      • Managing the R&D pipeline
      • Open Innovation
      • Roadmapping
      • Technology Strategy
    • Special Features
      • Innovation for a Sustainable Future
      • How to measure the value created by innovation
      • Dynamic capabilities for strategic innovation
      • Would a ‘Strategy Lab’ provide sustainable renewal of competitive advantage?
      • Design Thinking
      • China’s new model for Open Innovation
      • Penetrating the fog of Agile
      • The resurgence of frugal innovation
      • Impact of digital technologies
    • Key Conference Tracks
      • Business model innovation
      • Entrepreneurial Ecosystems, Innovation Ecosystems and platforms
      • Intellectual Property Rights
      • Sustainable Innovation
    • Innovation Leadership
  • RADMA
    • About RADMA
    • R&D Project Exchange
    • Celebrating 40 Years of RADMA
    • RADMA Scholars
    • R&D Management Journal
  • The Pentathlon Framework
    • Strategy
    • Ideas
    • Selection & Prioritisation
    • Implementation
    • People & Organisations
  • Knowledge Hub
  • R&D Management Conference
  • Events
    • Upcoming events
    • Events Archive
  • Contact
  • Home
  • About
    • About R&D Today
    • Contributors
    • R&D Publications
    • R&D Today newsletter archive
  • Themes
    • R&D Management
      • Rationale for key themes
      • Ideation and creativity in R&D
      • Managing international R&D
      • Managing the R&D pipeline
      • Open Innovation
      • Roadmapping
      • Technology Strategy
    • Special Features
      • Innovation for a Sustainable Future
      • How to measure the value created by innovation
      • Dynamic capabilities for strategic innovation
      • Would a ‘Strategy Lab’ provide sustainable renewal of competitive advantage?
      • Design Thinking
      • China’s new model for Open Innovation
      • Penetrating the fog of Agile
      • The resurgence of frugal innovation
      • Impact of digital technologies
    • Key Conference Tracks
      • Business model innovation
      • Entrepreneurial Ecosystems, Innovation Ecosystems and platforms
      • Intellectual Property Rights
      • Sustainable Innovation
    • Innovation Leadership
  • RADMA
    • About RADMA
    • R&D Project Exchange
    • Celebrating 40 Years of RADMA
    • RADMA Scholars
    • R&D Management Journal
  • The Pentathlon Framework
    • Strategy
    • Ideas
    • Selection & Prioritisation
    • Implementation
    • People & Organisations
  • Knowledge Hub
  • R&D Management Conference
  • Events
    • Upcoming events
    • Events Archive
  • Contact

Menu

Tool Fingerprinting: Characterising Management Tools

Management tools and techniques such as roadmapping, portfolio management methods and scenario planning are considered useful for a variety of business issues.

Practitioners are confused by the increasing number of management tools and techniques available as scholars, managers and consultants develop ever newer ways to support firms.

Academics have long been interested in understanding the nature of management tools and to derive guidance on how they should be used – a typical approach has been proposing rules and classifications, however none are universally recognised.

The trouble is that everyone has a different view of what tools are and what they could or could not do. There is not yet a map to help practitioners identify tools which could be integrated to create toolkits. There is a need for a more stable platform to treat management tools so that opportunities to configure and combine as well as integrate methods might become easier and to help practitioners with the configuration of toolkits (e.g. how do we know whether we have covered all that is needed? How do we know whether the current configuration of this roadmap is exhaustive? What other tools do we need/we could to add? How should we configure them?).

This paper proposes a map, derived from the characterisations of instances of tools implementation, according to five key dimensions which can help design and understand toolkits whilst in action.

These five dimensions are:

  1.  Application Domain
  2. Functions
  3. Implementation Techniques
  4. Business Aspects Considered
  5. Implementation metrics.

For each dimension, the paper describes the possible variations (for example, the implementation techniques of tools vary from workshop-based to interviews, to numerical simulations, modelling, role-playing, statistical analysis etc…) and shows how a toolkit could be fingerprinted.

A route is proposed in the paper which has its roots in the concept of ‘family resemblances.’ Accordingly five dimensions are derived from the analysis of extant literature which, the authors argue, provide the basis for a ‘general’ template for the analysis of each individual ‘tool-in-action’ which could help both practitioners in the configuration in the management tools/toolkits and academics in the analysis of trends in their use.

The new proposed approach is introduced and applied to an existing toolkit to show how this characterisation scheme can be employed both to assess existing tools and toolkits and to identify ways to improve and complement them with other tools.

The authors say: “We think this approach can also be particularly helpful for practitioners. By using the tool-in-action approach, discussions could be avoided regarding what is meant by the words ‘roadmapping’ or ‘portfolio management’.

“Similarly, speculations and assumptions with regards to what tools are meant to do could be avoided. Clearly seeing the fingerprint of each tool provides strong foundation for configuring and planning of toolkits and for communicating their benefits and characteristics.”

The paper concludes by reviewing the strengths and weaknesses of this approach for researchers and managers and areas for future research.

Taken from Tool Fingerprinting: Characterising Management Tools by L Mortara, R Phaal, C Kerr, C Farrukh and D Probert, Centre for Technology Management, Institute for Manufacturing, University of Cambridge.

  • 30 September 2020
View our newsletter archive
  • Related posts

    • Developing industrially relevant strategic technology management toolkits – a review
    • Direct coaching supports SMEs with inbound knowledge transfer from university
    • Technology roadmapping – a framework for evolution and revolution – a review
    • Business Appraisal of Technology Potentials – development of a practical approach to valuing technology
    • Sustaining roadmapping in commercial organisations – Subsea 7 case-study
    • Assessing innovation and technology management capabilities in an organisation
    • Portfolio management tools and approaches
    • Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA)
    • Must read papers on aspects of R&D Management
    • Improving the assessment of innovation and technology management capabilities
    • What do you think about roadmapping?
    • Visualizing Roadmaps: A Design-Driven Approach
  • Have your say

    Have your say / Follow us

    Linkedin Soundcloud Twitter Youtube Linkedin-in

    R&D Today is the outreach site for the Research and Development Management Association, a charitable organisation that supports research, best practice and innovation.  www.radma.net

    Click here to sign up to our newsletter, and
     click here to view our newsletter archive.

    © Copyright R&D Today

    2025.

    All rights reserved.