logologologo
  • Home
  • About
    • Contributors
    • Guide for contributors
  • Themes
    • Roadmapping
    • Open Innovation
    • Managing the R&D pipeline
    • Technology Strategy
    • Managing international R&D
    • Ideation and creativity in R&D
    • Impact of digital technologies
    • The resurgence of frugal innovation
    • Design Thinking
    • Penetrating the fog of Agile
    • China’s Belt and Road Initiative, a new model for Open Innovation
  • Tools
  • News
    • R&D Today newsletter archive
  • Resources
  • Papers
  • Case Studies
  • Events
  • R&D Conference
  • Contact
  • Home
  • About
    • Contributors
    • Guide for contributors
  • Themes
    • Roadmapping
    • Open Innovation
    • Managing the R&D pipeline
    • Technology Strategy
    • Managing international R&D
    • Ideation and creativity in R&D
    • Impact of digital technologies
    • The resurgence of frugal innovation
    • Design Thinking
    • Penetrating the fog of Agile
    • China’s Belt and Road Initiative, a new model for Open Innovation
  • Tools
  • News
    • R&D Today newsletter archive
  • Resources
  • Papers
  • Case Studies
  • Events
  • R&D Conference
  • Contact

Assessing the viability of emerging disruptive technology

Electric car - emerging disruptive technologiesWhat makes a disruptive technology successful?

According to Hardman et al, disruptive technologies share particular characteristics and these include being disruptive to market leaders, end users and infrastructure.

In their paper, Hardman et al identify seven characteristics of disruptive innovations. They use a three-point criteria derived from these characteristics and based on historical successful disruptive technologies to identify if a technology is or has the potential to be successful.

This creates a foundation from which to identify pathways to greater market penetration.

Seven characteristics of successful disruptive technologies

  1. The threat of the new technology is not often recognised by existing market leaders.
  2. Disruptive technologies are initially more expensive than the incumbent technologies.
  3. Often, the quality of the disruptive technology is initially worse than the quality of the technology it seeks to replace.
  4. The technologies have some form of desirable ‘added value’ to the consumer.
  5. Disruptive technologies fill niche markets first, before spreading to other niches and eventually reaching the mass market, where they then become most disruptive.
  6. The incumbent technology is never wiped out all together. It in turn becomes a technology for niche market applications.
  7. Socio-technical systems are ever-evolving. Incumbent technologies will be replaced by disruptive ones, and the disruptive ones will eventually become incumbent, which, in turn, will be made redundant by a new technology in the future.

These seven characteristics are not exclusive and not all successful disruptive technologies have these characteristics.

However, from these seven, the authors derive 3 fundamental characteristics, which, according to them, are always present in disruptive technologies and are exclusive to disruptive technologies. These form the three-point disruptive technology criteria, and barring the odd exception a disruptive technology will meet at least two of these three criteria.

The three-point disruptive technology criteria are:

  1. Disruptive to market leaders: the manufacturers of the disruptive technology are different companies to those producing the incumbent technologies.
  2. Disruptive to end users: disruptive technologies change the way in which the technologies are used.
  3. Disruptive to infrastructure: the disruptive technology requires different infrastructure to the incumbent technology and/or negatively affects existing infrastructure.

The authors explain that these criteria can be used to assess whether a technology that is at the point of market penetration is disruptive to the current market. Importantly, the criteria can also be used to predict whether a new technology has the potential to become a disruptive technology.

The successful use of the three-point criteria requires information regarding both the incumbent and the potential disruptor.

For example, for the incumbent, there is the need to establish:

– who the market leaders are in the disruptor’s target market
– how the technology is used
– what infrastructure the technology has associated with it.

For the disruptor, it is important to understand:

– who is producing the technology
– how the technology will be used
– how it performs better than the incumbent
– the nature of the infrastructure the disruptor will require to support its market entry.

Hardman et al note that if a technology is found to meet only one of the criteria it is likely to be a sustaining technology that will not cause disruption the status quo.

The full version of this paper can be found at http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0360319913023112  (Disruptive innovations: the case for hydrogen fuel cells and battery electric vehicles, International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 38 (2013) 15438 – 15451, Hardman et al (2013))

Written by Dr Imoh Ilevbare for R&D Today
Product Manager (Innovation and Technology Management Services) at Institute for Manufacturing, University of Cambridge

disruptive technologyImoh M.Ilevbaretechnology strategy
Previous PostRoadmapping at BASF
Next PostHow to identify disruptive technologies
Search R&D Today
Search
Generic filters
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Search in excerpt
Filter by Article Type
Papers
Events
Tools
Funding Articles
Case Studies
Resources
Opportunities
Theme Editor Blogs
Filter by Categories
Business model innovation
Ideation and creativity in R&D
Latest news
Managing international R&D
Managing technology platforms
Managing the R&D pipeline
Open innovation
Outsourcing R&D
Project valuation and selection
R&D strategy
Roadmapping
Stage gate processes
Technology intelligence
View our newsletter archive
Theme Editor Blogs
  • Digital disruption in the lab: The case for R&D digitalization in chemicals – a review
  • Accelerating product development: the tools you need now – a review
  • Using good practice R&D management to create new innovations in malodour control
Associated Papers
  • Direct coaching supports SMEs with inbound knowledge transfer from university
  • Assessing innovation and technology management capabilities in an organisation
  • Selection of good papers from Technovation
Resources
  • Transferring new ideas from research to practice
  • Technology acquisitions: A guided approach to technology acquisitions and protection decisions
  • A guided approach to technology acquisitions and protection decision
Related Posts
  • Product technology roadmapping – a visual framework for ‘sense making’ in a changing world
  • How do companies deal with potentially disruptive technologies?
  • Interesting papers from Technovation
Tools
  • Innovation Fitness Test - a tool to help scoring
    John Bessant recommends this tool developed by colleagues in Canada which helps with using...
  • Most useful R&D Management tools survey
    Most useful tools for R&D Management
    Ask which are the most useful tools for R&D Management and you will find...
  • Top Trumps with Joe De Sousa
    Using the game 'Top Trumps' as a communications tool
    Large R&D centric businesses have a huge asset in the vast experience that exists...
  • TRIZ Toolkit
    The challenge of applying TRIZ tool kit for ideation
    TRIZ (the theory of inventive problem solving) provides a logical approach to developing creativity...
  • Green Check Your Idea
    “Green Check Your Idea” – assess the environmental impact of innovation ideas
    The Green Check Your Idea tool helps innovation managers prepare an initial assessment of...
Have Your Say…

Have Your Say / Follow Us

R&D Today is the outreach site for the Research and Development Management Association, a charitable organisation that supports research, best practice and innovation.  www.radma.net

Click here to sign up to our newsletter, and click here to view our newsletter archive.

Copyright R&D Today 2020. All rights reserved.