logologologo
  • Home
  • About
    • Contributors
    • Guide for contributors
  • Themes
    • Roadmapping
    • Open Innovation
    • Managing the R&D pipeline
    • Technology Strategy
    • Managing international R&D
    • Ideation and creativity in R&D
    • Impact of digital technologies
    • The resurgence of frugal innovation
    • Design Thinking
    • Penetrating the fog of Agile
    • China’s Belt and Road Initiative, a new model for Open Innovation
  • Tools
  • News
    • R&D Today newsletter archive
  • Resources
  • Papers
  • Case Studies
  • Events
  • R&D Conference
  • Contact
  • Home
  • About
    • Contributors
    • Guide for contributors
  • Themes
    • Roadmapping
    • Open Innovation
    • Managing the R&D pipeline
    • Technology Strategy
    • Managing international R&D
    • Ideation and creativity in R&D
    • Impact of digital technologies
    • The resurgence of frugal innovation
    • Design Thinking
    • Penetrating the fog of Agile
    • China’s Belt and Road Initiative, a new model for Open Innovation
  • Tools
  • News
    • R&D Today newsletter archive
  • Resources
  • Papers
  • Case Studies
  • Events
  • R&D Conference
  • Contact

How Air Products and Chemicals Inc overcame silo mentality

Concerned that it was losing competitive edge, the US company Air Products and Chemicals Inc, centralised its external technology efforts in a move towards open innovation. It formed Corporate Technology Partnerships to implement best practices across the company.

Before this move there had been little coordination between coordination of efforts between business areas and R&D groups, a situation that had been described as a ‘silo mentality’, with no coordination of work processes or central repository of best practices and the resulting contracts.

John Tao, corporate director of technology partnerships at Air Products, and Vincent Magnotta, manager of technology transfer, produced a paper about their experiences that is one of the best cited on Research Technology Management. 

The authors identified the most notable driving forces for open innovation as being:

  • Increased pressure for faster, better and lower cost R&D;
  • Realisation that no company has more than one per cent of global R&D capacity;
  • Reduced inflow of scientific talent to the US;
  • Recognition that the US was being surpassed in science education as evidenced by annual doctorate degrees granted.

The paper “How Air Products and Chemicals ‘identifies and accelerates'” reviews the process of identifying corporate technical needs and the role of external partnering played in accelerating the innovation process.

The external partnering strategies reviewed:

  • global R&D insourcing
  • internet-based providers
  • partnering with the government
  • licensing in.

Air Products’ approach to open innovation was to ‘identify and accelerate’, identifying and prioritising the key technical needs and using a toolbox of approaches to accelerate solutions to those needs. This approach enabled the company to innovate faster, better and at lower cost.

LNG heat exchanger - Open Innovation

A completed LNG heat exchanger manufactured at Air Products’ Port Manatee facility – the company has reinvigorated itself with international operations

However, everything was not plain sailing, when the company began introducing open innovation it met internal challenges as historically over 95 per cent of its R&D budget had been earmarked for internal development. The initial problem was budgeting sufficiently to include open innovation in the R&D portfolio, but as the company became more successful at open innovation its external budget increased.

A second challenge was grassroots resistance from the internal technical community. Some members viewed open innovation as a threat to their job security. In the closed innovation model technical community members were expected to invent everything internally and be rewarded accordingly. One way to overcome this resistance was to reward the technical community based on its ability to solve technical problems – regardless of the source of the solutions.

The authors conclude that open innovation is here to stay and that the fraction of a successful company’s R&D budget devoted to open innovation will need to grow. Warning that companies that choose to remain internally focused for solutions to their technology needs will be left behind.

Taken from How Air Products and Chemicals ‘identifies and accelerates’ by John Tao and Vincent Magnotta published in Research Technology Management in 2006.

Air Products and ChemicalsJohn Taoopen innovationVincent Magnotta
Previous PostHow to protect know-how and trade secrets in ...
Next PostWhat are the ten major trends affecting produ...
Search R&D Today
Search
Generic filters
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Search in excerpt
Filter by Article Type
Papers
Events
Tools
Funding Articles
Case Studies
Resources
Opportunities
Theme Editor Blogs
Filter by Categories
Business model innovation
Ideation and creativity in R&D
Latest news
Managing international R&D
Managing technology platforms
Managing the R&D pipeline
Open innovation
Outsourcing R&D
Project valuation and selection
R&D strategy
Roadmapping
Stage gate processes
Technology intelligence
View our newsletter archive
Theme Editor Blogs
  • Digital disruption in the lab: The case for R&D digitalization in chemicals – a review
  • Accelerating product development: the tools you need now – a review
  • Using good practice R&D management to create new innovations in malodour control
Associated Papers
  • Open Innovation between established and emerging bio-pharmaceuticals
  • Direct coaching supports SMEs with inbound knowledge transfer from university
  • Reinventing supplier innovation relationships – nine key findings
Resources
  • Innovation Management: Learning for the experiences of companies in European countries
  • How to write and publish your research
  • Top 20 Innovation Blogs of 2016
Related Posts
  • Open Innovation the Chinese way
  • Ten ways to design successful corporate startup collaborations
  • Collaborative innovation in a time of social distancing – 5 things we now know
Tools
  • Frugal Innovation Index
    Frugal innovation - competitive advantage when resources are limited
    Frugal innovation allows a company with a quality product to compete effectively with cheaper...
  • Most useful R&D Management tools survey
    Most useful tools for R&D Management
    Ask which are the most useful tools for R&D Management and you will find...
  • Kano model of product or service features 2
    Improving Product Features: When is More Less?
    Different types of feature have different effects on customer satisfaction - analysis by Quality...
  • Innovation Fitness Test - a tool to help scoring
    John Bessant recommends this tool developed by colleagues in Canada which helps with using...
  • Paul Barrett
    Tools support objective discussion of portfolio strategy
    Paul Barrett is part of a RADMA working group providing a selection of recommended...
Have Your Say…

Have Your Say / Follow Us

R&D Today is the outreach site for the Research and Development Management Association, a charitable organisation that supports research, best practice and innovation.  www.radma.net

Click here to sign up to our newsletter, and click here to view our newsletter archive.

Copyright R&D Today 2020. All rights reserved.